Mar 20, 2023
Gamers Hate Orson Scott Card
The controversy about Shadow Complex, Orson Scott Card, and gay rights – This is an important one for Christian gamers to pay attention to. Lots of interesting things going on here.
Richard Clark
Richard Clark is the Founding Editor of Christ and Pop Culture. He is also the managing editor of Gamechurch and a freelance writer for Unwinnable, Paste, and other outlets. He lives with his wife in Louisville, KY and has a MA in Theology and the Arts from the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.
Get Our Weekly Newsletter
Get our weekly recap email for the latest from CAPC, delivered straight to your inbox.
Become a CAPC Member
Support our work: Become a member and get exclusive membership perks.
Give a CAPC Membership
Introduce friends & colleagues to the CAPC world with a gift membership.
Be a Guest Writer
Learn more about writing for us.
Editor Picks
Recent Columns

Mar 14, 2023
He Don’t Want That Smoke: A King’s Advice to Ja Morant

Feb 28, 2023
Super Bowl LVII Reminds Us to Sit with Black (Sports) History a Little Longer

Jan 31, 2023
Maya Moore: Love and (No More) Basketball

Jan 17, 2023
Lamar Jackson’s Injury Proves We’ve Learned Nothing From Damar Hamlin’s Cardiac Arrest

Jan 10, 2023
2022 Sports Roundup, 4th Quarter
Recent Podcasts

Mar 24, 2023
Seeing & Believing 374 | John Wick: Chapter 4 & The Warriors (1979)

Mar 23, 2023
The Scandal of Reading 20 | Kaitlyn Schiess on Dorothy L. Sayers’ Zeal of thy House

Mar 22, 2023
Seeing and Believing March 2023 Bonus | Inherit the Wind with Truce Podcast

Mar 17, 2023
Seeing and Believing 373 | 65 & All Is Lost

Mar 16, 2023
2 Comments
I think this becomes more amusing when one considers that the game’s writer, Peter David, has (if memory serves) a portfolio containing many gay-friendly characterizations. In short, he couldn’t be realistically seen as supporting Card’s anti-homosexual stance at all.
Chick’s response to David’s admonition that those opposing Card’s perspective “can display the sort of tolerance for someone who is different from them that they feel is lacking in Orson and thus prove they’re better” is, frankly, inadequate. He misses David’s point by creating a false dichotomy, positing that one can only respond with either blanket intolerance or blanket tolerance. Never mind the option of offering tolerance while offering critical discourse and persuasive discussion.
The gamers who boycott over Card’s connection to the game (despite the lack of offending content within the game itself) are behaving just as irrationally as those Christians who boycotted products advertised during NYPD Blue episodes or those that refuse any Disney products based on Disney’s employee benefits program.
I guess the newsflash here would be: PEOPLE STILL BLINDLY INTOLERANT OF THOSE WITH WHOM THEY DISAGREE.
You’re right. This whole debate has discouraged me quite a bit and left me wondering if there’s room at all for a game critic who refers to himself as a critic.
Comments are now closed for this article.